More than half of landlords now say they're more likely to request a guarantor from tenants who don't comfortably meet standard affordability checks, according to research from LRG published this week. The shift follows the Renters' Rights Act cap on rent in advance, which removed landlords' ability to request more than one month upfront. Yet 74% of tenants are unaware that professional guarantor services exist, and 51% say they would simply search for cheaper properties if asked for a guarantor. The mismatch creates a practical bottleneck for agents: landlords are tightening vetting criteria at precisely the moment most borderline applicants lack knowledge of the workaround.
The LRG survey found that 28% of landlords said their approach to guarantors had not changed, while 13% had always required one in marginal cases. That leaves 51% reporting they're now more likely to request a guarantor from applicants who don't comfortably meet affordability thresholds. The timing aligns with the Renters' Rights Act restriction, which limits rent in advance to one month and removes what landlords previously used as a buffer against perceived arrears risk.
Allison Thompson, Chief Lettings Officer at Leaders, said: "Landlords need confidence that a tenancy is affordable and sustainable, particularly now that rent in advance is no longer available as an additional safeguard."
The tenant response problem
When asked what they would do if they needed a guarantor but lacked a family member or friend able to act, 51% of tenants said they would look for a cheaper rental property. A further 16% said they would stop their search entirely. Only 18% said they would use a professional guarantor service, and 15% selected another option.
The low uptake intention reflects the awareness gap: nearly three-quarters of tenants told LRG they were unaware of professional guarantor services. That leaves agents managing applicants who hit a guarantor requirement, assume they have no options, and either downgrade their search or exit the market. For landlords with voids to fill and agents chasing let fees, that's a direct commercial cost.
Professional guarantor providers such as Housing Hand and Rent Guarantor stand to benefit if awareness rises, but the current knowledge gap is material. The sector hasn't yet built distribution or consumer recognition at scale, and agents are the natural intermediary. Whether agents formally partner with guarantor services, recommend them case-by-case, or leave tenants to discover them independently will shape void periods and conversion rates over the next two quarters.
What the research doesn't show
LRG has not disclosed sample size, methodology or fieldwork dates for the survey, so representativeness is unknown. The claim that landlords are responding directly to the Renters' Rights Act cap is asserted by LRG and supported by Thompson, but no temporal data showing guarantor requests before and after the legislation took effect has been provided.
The 51% figure reflects landlords saying they're "more likely" to request a guarantor, not that they have operationally implemented the change in every marginal case. There is no breakdown by tenant demographic, income band or region to show which cohorts are most affected, and no data on actual arrears rates, void periods or let conversion since the Act came into force.
LRG is itself a rent guarantee insurance provider, which creates a commercial incentive to highlight gaps in landlord security and tenant awareness. That doesn't invalidate the findings, but it does warrant caution before treating the survey as a sector-wide baseline.
