The case demonstrates how target-driven performance systems in agencies become enforceable liabilities when they do not account for statutory maternity and flexible working rights. Stewart, employed since March 2022 and described as a 'strong performer', resigned in September 2025 after her line manager told her that targets would not be reduced to reflect either her part-time hours or the lower volume of leads allocated to her.
What the tribunal found
Stewart disclosed her pregnancy in July 2024 and explicitly asked her line manager not to share the information beyond those who needed to know for work purposes, given her history of miscarriages. The line manager disclosed it on a team call regardless. Stewart moved to virtual working due to morning sickness and applied to return part-time in December 2024, citing childcare responsibilities.
The tribunal heard that a meeting Stewart believed would discuss her health instead focused on performance criticism. She was told she was not meeting the required standard and that working part-time was not compatible with her role. Her targets were not adjusted for reduced hours, and she was allocated fewer leads than before maternity leave but expected to meet the same conversion metrics.
Stewart raised grievances about the mismatch between workload and targets. The tribunal was told these were not resolved. She was prescribed anti-depressants and anti-anxiety medication, lost weight, experienced sleep disruption, and developed vitiligo that her GP linked to stress. She resigned on 2 September 2025 after being told her targets would not be reduced, contrary to the outcome of her grievance.
The tribunal ruled that Purplebricks directly discriminated against Stewart because she had been on maternity leave and because of her sex. It found she was 'subjected to criticism on her performance which was unreasonable and required to meet targets which were not adjusted to reflect her part time hours or the level of referrals made to her'. The judgment stated: 'The treatment was wholly unreasonable and was designed to push the claimant out of her role as the respondent did not want a woman with childcare responsibilities working in her role. The claimant was criticised for not taking calls in the evenings, when she had childcare responsibilities.'
The compliance gap in KPI adjustment
Part-time employees returning from maternity leave have statutory rights to pro-rated performance targets. Failure to adjust KPIs proportionately can constitute indirect sex discrimination if the requirement disadvantages women disproportionately, and direct discrimination if the tribunal infers the employer's motive was connected to maternity or caregiving.
The tribunal's language is instructive. It did not find merely that Purplebricks failed to adjust targets. It concluded the failure was 'designed to push the claimant out', and that 'a man in similar circumstances (who had returned from a period of leave) would not have been treated in the same manner'. That suggests either documented evidence of intent or a pattern of conduct the tribunal found incompatible with any legitimate business rationale.
Agencies using commission or lead-conversion targets face particular risk. If a part-time returner receives fewer leads than full-time colleagues but is held to the same absolute conversion target, the performance gap becomes structural rather than individual. If the agency then uses that gap as grounds for performance criticism or capability proceedings, it exposes itself to claims that the system itself is discriminatory.
The tribunal awarded Stewart £27,626.73 in compensation, £18,647 for injury to feelings, and a £1,050 basic award. The injury to feelings award, likely in the middle Vento band (currently £11,200 to £33,700 for awards made in 2024–2025), indicates the tribunal found the discriminatory conduct serious or prolonged. Medical evidence strengthened the claim: anti-depressants, weight loss, sleep disruption and stress-related vitiligo provided objective corroboration of the injury.
Who pays, and what happens next
The award was made against Purplebricks Group PLC, the dissolved entity that employed Stewart. Purplebricks Group PLC did not participate in the proceedings. The tribunal noted 'the respondent did not seek to be part of the proceedings', raising questions about service, procedural compliance and enforceability.
Purplebricks Property, the current operator following Strike's acquisition of the business, states it was unaware of the case because proceedings were issued to the old company's lawyers before the takeover. The company says it was not named as a respondent and therefore 'not a party to the Tribunal process or able to participate in the proceedings'. It adds that 'the circumstances surrounding the case are being reviewed and, in view of the legal issues arising, we are unable to comment further'.
Whether Stewart can recover the £47,323 from the dissolved entity, pursue successor liability claims against Purplebricks Property, or seek payment from insurers is not yet clear. Successor liability in employment claims depends on whether the new operator is a legal successor under TUPE or took on employment liabilities as part of the business transfer. No detail on those arrangements has been disclosed.
Purplebricks Property's statement that 'more than half of our employees are parents' and its commitment to 'fostering an inclusive and supportive working environment' does not address the systemic issue: whether its current target-setting and performance management systems adjust proportionately for part-time staff and document flexible working discussions in a way that would withstand tribunal scrutiny.
