Scotland's Programme for Government, announced by First Minister John Swinney this week, has delivered no substantive measures on property taxation, landlord operating costs or tribunal resourcing, despite the country's declared housing emergency. Letting agents, portfolio landlords and property managers north of the border now face continuing cost pressures with no statutory relief and new transactional friction from measures whose operational detail remains unpublished.
Propertymark has criticised the programme for omitting the fiscal and structural reforms the sector had called for. Timothy Douglas, Head of Policy and Campaigns at Propertymark, said housing was "barely mentioned" in Swinney's speech, and that measures to reduce costs and taxes for renters, buyers and sellers were absent. The programme reaffirms commitment to the First Homes Fund and affordable homes delivery but provides no route to easing the cost base for private landlords or their tenants.
Missing fiscal measures and cost pass-through
Douglas argues that property tax reductions historically drive transaction volumes and that lower landlord costs translate to lower rents. No citation, time period or jurisdiction is provided for the first claim, and the second assumes full cost pass-through in a market where rent controls already limit landlords' pricing power. The sector has long sought LBTT reform, particularly at thresholds affecting portfolio acquisitions and higher-value residential sales, but the Programme for Government makes no reference to transaction tax changes.
Landlords operating under Scotland's licensing regimes, energy efficiency standards and rent control framework face compounding costs with no offsetting incentive. In the absence of relief, those costs will continue to flow through rent increases where permitted, or drive further portfolio exits where they cannot. Letting agents should prepare for landlords to test rent caps at every statutory review point and to scrutinise compliance spend more closely.
Council Tax bands and the valuation risk
The Council Tax (Scotland) Bill will introduce two additional bands for higher-value properties, a measure Douglas describes as a "Mansion Tax" that will "only target a small minority of properties". No data on how many properties fall into the prospective new bands, or revenue estimates, has been published. The risk for agents and conveyancers is procedural: valuation disputes at the upper end may delay transactions and deter investment in properties close to band thresholds.
If the new bands replicate the valuation appeal routes available under current Council Tax legislation, expect an uptick in assessor challenges and a lengthening of completion timelines for affected sales. Portfolio landlords and institutional buyers will price in the risk, and agents should flag it early in valuations and marketing strategies for properties likely to fall into or near the new bands.
Tenant right of first refusal and transaction friction
The programme includes a tenant right of first refusal to purchase their rented property. No operational framework, consultation timeline or evidence base has been disclosed. If modelled on social housing transfer schemes, this measure could delay or complicate portfolio sales and the termination of assured shorthold tenancies where a landlord intends to sell with vacant possession.
Agents need clarity on notification periods, valuation methodology, tenant financing requirements and the interaction with existing marketing and sales processes. Until guidance is published, the prudent course is to assume additional lead time for any portfolio disposal involving sitting tenants and to document landlord intentions early. Douglas calls for the measure to be "workable and evidence based", but no consultation mechanism has been announced.
Tribunal resourcing and dispute backlogs
Douglas also called for better resourcing of the First Tier Tribunal for Scotland (Housing and Property Chamber), which handles rent determinations, eviction applications and tenancy disputes. Under-resourcing leads to case backlogs, delaying possession and rent adjustments for landlords and prolonging uncertainty for tenants. The Programme for Government makes no mention of additional tribunal funding or administrative capacity.
Letting agents and property managers should continue to factor tribunal delays into possession timelines and rent review strategies. Where rent control regimes permit increases, document the economic case thoroughly to reduce the risk of challenge and appeal. The absence of tribunal investment suggests no improvement in case processing times through 2027.
