Regulation Monitor

Unverified £750m dormant deposit claim pushes reconciliation onto reform agenda

Software firm estimates £750m in dormant deposits with no verification or methodology disclosed. Agents face no reconciliation obligation.

PBI NewsroomPublished Editorial direction by Jamie Adams and David Adams
Illustrative image: Unverified £750m dormant deposit claim pushes reconciliation onto reform agenda

A software provider has claimed that around £750 million in tenancy deposits may be sitting dormant in England and Wales' protection system, with no legislative framework or reporting mechanism to track them. The Letting Partnership published the estimate in October and is arguing that the government's current deposit reform review should address what it calls a governance gap. The claim raises questions about agent liability, reconciliation obligations and whether Scotland's existing dormant deposit legislation provides a workable model.

The estimate has not been independently verified and The Letting Partnership has not disclosed its methodology, data sources or sample size. No deposit protection scheme has publicly confirmed or challenged the figure. The assertion that "nobody can say with confidence what the true scale actually is" sits uncomfortably alongside a precise £750 million estimate.

What agents currently hold

Letting agents in England and Wales protect deposits through one of three custodial or insured schemes. Custodial schemes hold the funds directly. Insured schemes allow agents to retain the deposit while paying for insurance against non-compliance or loss. Neither model requires systematic reconciliation of protected deposits against live tenancies once a tenancy ends.

That creates a scenario where deposits can remain in the system indefinitely if neither tenant nor landlord claims them. Agents are responsible for administering these balances but have no clear process for dealing with funds that cannot be returned because parties cannot be traced or have not responded.

The Letting Partnership has not clarified whether its estimate includes custodial balances only, insured scheme liabilities, or both. Nor has it explained how it arrived at the figure or what assumptions underpin the modelling. Deposit schemes holding custodial funds may accrue interest on those balances, raising further questions about who benefits from long-term dormant deposits and what reserves schemes hold against potential future claims.

Scotland's precedent

Scotland has legislated for dormant tenancy deposits, establishing a process to redirect eligible unclaimed funds to housing-related causes after safeguards and timeframes are met. Chris Mason, COO at The Letting Partnership, argues that England and Wales should follow that model to bring transparency to long-term unclaimed balances.

Mason said: "At present, there is no legislative framework in England and Wales governing dormant tenancy deposits, nor is there any official reporting mechanism that reconciles deposits held within the protection schemes against those that remain active within letting agents' portfolios."

He added: "Our modelling suggests the figure could be significant, potentially running into the hundreds of millions of pounds, but without that reconciliation mechanism in place, nobody can say with confidence what the true scale actually is."

The Scottish legislation has not been detailed in this intervention. No information is available on the timeframes agents must wait before surrendering balances, the trace procedures required, the safeguards for tenants and landlords who later resurface, or how much money has been redirected to date. Without that data, it is difficult to assess whether the model has worked in practice or what cost and compliance burden it has imposed on Scottish agents.

The compliance exposure

If government adopts a Scotland-style framework, agents will face new obligations. They will likely need to track time elapsed since tenancy end, maintain records of attempts to contact former tenants and landlords, and surrender balances to a designated body after a statutory period. That introduces administrative cost, potential audit exposure and questions about liability if a tenant or landlord later disputes the surrender.

Deposit protection schemes holding custodial funds may face pressure to transfer dormant balances, affecting their financial models and reserve requirements. Insured schemes will need clarity on whether their liability ends when a deposit is declared dormant or whether they remain on risk for future claims.

Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook confirmed earlier this year that government is considering removing insured tenancy deposit schemes as part of a wider review of the tenancy deposit protection system. That review has focused on custodial versus insured models. Governance of dormant balances has not featured prominently in consultation documents or ministerial statements to date.

The Letting Partnership's intervention may push dormant deposits onto the policy agenda, but the lack of supporting evidence and the absence of scheme-level data weakens the case. If the £750 million figure is even broadly accurate, deposit schemes and government both have questions to answer about why reconciliation has not been a regulatory or reporting priority.

What happens next

Government's deposit reform review is ongoing. Any consultation response or draft legislation will clarify whether dormant deposits and reconciliation obligations are in scope. The Renters' Rights Bill, currently progressing through Parliament, may provide a legislative vehicle for new requirements if ministers decide to act.

Agents should monitor whether new reporting or surrender obligations emerge. Deposit protection schemes may publish their own analysis or comment on unclaimed balances, particularly if the £750 million estimate gains traction. Scottish data on redirected funds would provide evidence for or against extending the model, but none has been cited.

If reconciliation requirements are introduced, agents will need systems capable of tracking deposit lifecycles beyond tenancy end. Software providers, including The Letting Partnership, will be well-placed to offer those tools. That commercial reality does not invalidate the policy question, but it does explain the timing and positioning of this intervention.

Source notes

This article was written from the trade reporting below. The analysis and the PBI Take are ours; we have not independently verified the underlying facts.